Welcome! Contact Us | Buy Our Magazine |Contribute an Article | Investing in Zambia | Shop at our store | Advertise with Us | Facebook | Twitter |

UKZAMBIANS

Alienating investors who are helping our country

By George Jere

A mine worker looks on underground

History has the answers to this vexatious problem in Zambia, events tend to repeat themselves.

It was not a long time ago, year 1992 when one major mining company Anglo American abandoned us, Luanshya town was also abandoned, and a major economic upheaval beset the country, as copper prices plummeted.

A Painful restructuring process had to be instituted in Zambia under the HIPC (highly indebted poor nation).The people of Zambia had to make painful sacrifices for the next 10 to 15 years. Important to the success of Zambia’s restructuring process was the attraction of foreign investors to this country. And they responded due to the favorable liberalization policies we had instituted
for the first time in 40 years our copper production reached pre-independence levels of 700,000mt.GDP has reached 6to7% among the highest in the world. New towns like Solwezi have sprung up….and most importantly we are no longer classified a highly indebted nation.

Then we want to turn around today and blame the people (investors) who responded favorably to our call…amazing but it is happening …perhaps a preamble to Zambia’s economic reforms of 1968?

In the forefront of promoting the above allegation is Publish what you earn people (PWYP) a loose body of Christian organizations, trade unions and other civil societies. A discerning look at the PWYP composition reveals it is devoid of economists, financial analysts. Certainly one cannot expect a balanced opinion on financial affairs from such a group to begin with.
It is important to note that all public companies operating in Zambia are subject to independent audits by Zambian owned auditing firms. And the mining companies have mostly Zambian accountants who prepare their books.

According to the daily mail of 14/11/12 Mr. Sikamo a Zambian metallurgist with Chibuluma mine reviewed that it costs$7150 to produce a tone of copper. The current price is $7770 per tonne, meaning the mining net profit is a mere 8%.in lay mans term; the mine gets k8 profit from every k100 sold.

The World Bank report has also listed Zambia as a country with the highest operational cost and that include in the extraction of copper.
Now let’s examine the PWYP allegation and I quote:”From 2004 to 2006 Zambia’s mining tax was only 3.4% of gross sales…..”

Yes that is true because Zambia’s tax rate of 35% if applied to the 8% profit above Results in 2.8% or round off to 3 % tax to gross sales, comparable to PWYP findings of 3.4%of gross sales.

Ignorance is blissful and also dangerous. The PWYP is unwittingly inciting false feelings of injustice that the Zambian people are being exploited.
The assertion by the Deputy Minister Hon. Miles Sampa that Zambia is losing a third of its budget through tax avoidance can only amount to a figment of imagination whose sole aim is to alienate the very investors who are helping our country to move to a prosperous future.

Related other websites Links

Learn more the author of this post:

George Jere
George Jere is a correspondent of UK mail magazine on economy and political Affairs. A Matero boys school leaver and a graduate of a diploma in accountancy from Evelyn hone college in the 1980. He worked as a senior in Peat Marwick & Mitchell (KPMG) and was a business consultant to Simba milling for so many years. He left Zambia to UK in 2005 and lives with his wife and two adult sons as the managing Director of nkosimarketing.co.uk and recently incorporated GX Energy (Z), a company promoting renewable energy in Zambia dealing in Solar, Bio-Fuels, Waste and Hydro Energy.
 
Comments

Hello my loved one! I want to say that this article is awesome, great written and
come with almost all important infos. I would like to look extra posts like this .

Daniel thanks very much for your comment.unfortunately when one tries to access the BBC site from this end you draw a blank.It is only opened for Uk viewers only.Hmm a strange one…

Picking up from your comment that some  multi nationals exporting copper are under pricing to associate companies abroad….This is not possible.
All exports from Zambia are subject to an export licence.The regulations demand detailed specifications of the item and the agreed contract price in case of copper.the Zambia standards bureau(ZSB ) then certifies that the quantity and price are according to the contracts and compatible with the pricing on the London stock exchange.Each truck has it’s own authorisation papers and an export levy per truck is paid to ZSB.The bottomline ,the Zambian government would have been the first to notice the anomaly of under pricing.
Needless to mention both internal and external auditors to the mines in our country are zambians.
The introductory statement by the BBC on the  glencore chief is a cheap attempt at character assassination .The mere mention of the presence of a rich man in a Swedish town and that he has made his fortune in Zambia where poverty is rife  would only invoke feelings of anger in some people.
The BBC report has withheld information that glencore bosses earned their riches from trading well before coming to Zambia in the last 10years.
Their exponential accumulation of wealth was a a result of a recent successful floatation of the company’s shares from private to public.
The  company has not been accused or faced tax evasion charges in Zambia as alleged by the BBC report.

I’m not the only skeptic of the BBC.The past two years we have seen the BBC attacked in Uk  parliament for their shortcomings and among other things their left leaning views.The BBC chief had to resign last year and was replaced. It appears from these poverty reports that there are still vestiges of left leaning views in BBC.
The campaign by BBC on multi nationals is from time immemorial and unrelenting.But what is on the table are few cases of impropriety brought to fore by respective governments where these  multi nationals operate.Most multi-national companies are above board and Africa is well advised to join them in the creation of wealth.So that together we can fight the  dehumanising effects of poverty on our continent.

“And let us not forget  the major root cause of poverty lies in the attitudes of people ”

Sent from my iPad

I hear what you are saying about the BBC, however perhaps this can not be said of all publications. Please research this further.

Transfer Pricing by companies such as Glencore is unfortunately legal in an international setting. In the Zambian mining sector and across the continent this practice consisting of selling processed ore between branches of the same company at knockdown prices in order to shift money out of the country and dodge taxes.
This is not unusual in multinational giants like Glencore. There is endless information in the public domain should you want to look this up.

Artificially Inflating production costs is another way the reduce their Tax bill to the Zambian people.

There is also the misrepresentation of quality and content of processed ore being exported. For instance exporting high value metal mixed with or declared as low grade metal.

Countries like great Britain have faced this problem from gigantic multinational entities with their platoon of international corporate Tax and Business law specialists.

So it goes without saying that Zambia has been a victim of this. There is a lot of suffering in Zambia, it is monumentally upsetting for even one dollar to be cheated out of us via these morally bankrupt tactics.

Have you read the environmental pollution report with regards to pollution levels resulting from mines in Kitwe and Chingola. It is more than a 100 times the acceptable limit stated by WHO. How much are they doing to help affected families in the copper mining towns??. It begs the question what has the Minister in charge got to say.

In case you have not grasped the level of publicity the earlier mentioned documentary has had, it makes us look like we are unable to look out for our selves. Just who is representing those without a voice, the poor hand to mouth ordinary Zambian

Please watch or read about a documentary on BBC (why poverty stealing africa). It is very insightful. Basically some investors are exporting / selling copper to their sister companies abroad cheaply and declaring low revenue on which they pay less tax to Zambian government. There after the sister company sells on the same copper at market price making hefty profits. Its majorly upsetting.

 
Comments